A woman who had been in an abusive relationship read Enmeshment Is Ursula. She was looking for love again. She thought the book was wonderful.
The part I keep coming back to is that she wanted to love again. That’s a desire worth taking seriously in its own right.
You may want someone to come home to that you can stand. You may want the peace of mind that comes with being able to say what’s on your mind and trust that the person beside you will still be glad to see you in the morning.
There’s a world of difference between choosing to give your time and spending it trying to stay in somebody’s good graces.
Enmeshment can make the desire for closeness so expensive that you start to wonder whether the only way to have peace is to stay single. Before you make a decision about love itself, it helps to understand what made it so costly the last time.
What is enmeshment in an adult relationship?
Enmeshment is a pattern in which closeness repeatedly interferes with your ability to make your own decisions, have a private life, or speak for yourself. A partner treats time alone as a sign you’re pulling away.
Your friendships are up for approval. You tell them you’re tired and they tell you what you’re really feeling.
After enough conversations like that, it can take considerable effort to hold on to your own account of a perfectly uneventful day.
Research with married couples has found that warmth and caregiving can be measured separately from intrusiveness. More recent research on individuality in adult couples looks at whether a partner respects your opinions and whether you feel free to have friends, interests, and space of your own.
You can be devoted to someone and spend a great deal of time together.
You can also take a trip with a friend, change your mind about something important, or disagree about a conversation and still feel loved when you get home. Those freedoms tell you more about the relationship than the number of hours you spend together. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
How enmeshment starts, and who benefits when it continues
Some forms of enmeshment grow out of rules nobody remembers choosing. A family may have treated privacy as secrecy for generations.
Two adults may sincerely believe that loving each other means telling each other everything and making every decision together. They may only discover the cost of that arrangement when one of them wants to do something alone.
Even when the pattern grew without a plan, it can distribute freedom unevenly. One person gets the reassurance of being consulted about everything.
The other has to negotiate for an afternoon to themselves.
Some experiences are done deliberately. I want to be plain about that because the word enmeshment can make it sound as though two people simply got tangled up.
Sometimes one person is doing the work of getting free while the other is doing the work of keeping them there.
In coercive control, a person uses a pattern of abusive behavior to restrict another person’s agency.
Coercive control is a pattern of abusive behavior that restricts another person’s freedom. In their research on intimate partner violence, Mary Ann Dutton and Lisa Goodman describe how a demand gains force through a credible consequence for refusing it.
Monitoring can be used to find out whether the person complied. Once someone has experienced the consequence, a partner may rarely need to spell it out.
The pattern can include demands backed by credible threats, monitoring, isolation, or control over money.
A partner may insist you stop seeing a friend, check your messages to see whether you complied, and punish you if you didn’t.
Once a consequence is established, the demand may never need to be made in full again. You know what happened last time.
If you’re trying to understand a relationship, ask who gets the reassurance, the access, or the final say. Then ask who gives up privacy, friendships, sleep, or hours of the day to keep things settled.
Those answers can show you the arrangement more clearly than another evening spent trying to understand why the other person behaves as they do.
When perfectionism is the fear of being in trouble
If a partner has repeatedly treated your independence as a personal offense, you may start preparing your defense before you’ve done anything at all.
You write a message, reread it for anything they could take badly, and add an explanation to a sentence that was clear the first time. The amount of work you put into a message can tell you something about what you expect to happen after you send it.
Lisa Feldman Barrett’s account of prediction offers one way to understand why the reaction can arrive so quickly. Past experience helps shape what you expect from a pause, a changed tone, or a short reply.
There’s also a reason the editing habit can last.
- Sometimes the extra explanation brings back the warmth.
- Sometimes it buys you an hour of peace.
Learning research on intermittent reinforcement helps explain why an effort can persist when it pays off only some of the time. The relief is immediate.
The cost may be harder to see until you realize how much of your evening you spent trying to get one sentence right.
What am I afraid will happen if this is not perfect?
Be specific. Maybe you expect to be called selfish or to spend the next two hours defending a friendship.
Then ask what has actually happened when I’ve made a decision this person didn’t like? The first question tells you what you’re preparing for.
The second gives you evidence about this relationship. Fear can travel with you into a new one. It can also tell you something accurate about the one you’re in.
Why the urge to get the words right persists
If keeping a preference has repeatedly led to criticism, withdrawal, or a dispute about your character, you have a reason to pay attention to the first sign of trouble.
In Lisa Feldman Barrett’s account of predictive processing, past experience helps shape what the brain expects in the present. A change in tone can be enough to bring the rest of a familiar exchange to mind.
You start revising the answer while you’re still giving it.
What do you want love to feel like now?
After a relationship where so much attention went to preventing trouble, you may have a detailed account of what you want to avoid and only the beginnings of an answer about what you want.
Give that second question some time.
- What would you look forward to on the drive home?
- How would you like to feel after an evening together?
- What would you like to be doing with the hours you used to spend worrying?
I think peace of mind belongs in that answer. So does sound health. I want to sleep well, laugh easily, and have enough attention left for the things I care about. I want to be able to look forward to seeing somebody.
I want the freedom to give generously when I choose to. A labor of love can be one of the pleasures of being alive when you get to decide where your love goes.
If you’re getting to know someone, notice how you feel after they’ve learned something real about you. Perhaps you tell them you like a great deal of time alone, or that a friendship from before you met matters deeply to you.
Do they become curious? Do they remember what you said? Can they learn something about you that they would never have guessed and enjoy knowing you a little better?
You may be looking for love again because you have a real appetite for it. The hope itself is worth keeping. So is the voice you’ll use to tell somebody what would make you happy.
Enmeshment Is Ursula: How to Reclaim Your Voice from the Tentacles
I wrote Enmeshment Is Ursula because the fairy tale lays out the bargain in full. Ariel gets a chance at a life she’s longed for, and the price is her voice.
Think about what she would have wanted to tell someone when she arrived. Where she came from. What she missed. What she liked about him. What she had in mind for the life she’d just gone to such lengths to reach.
The book follows that bargain in six chapters. It begins with The Contract, when the terms can still feel like the price of being loved.
The Voice Theft and The Tentacles look at how the agreement takes hold in conversations, habits, and the things you keep to yourself.
The Shape Loss asks what happens when you’ve adapted so thoroughly that you can barely say what you’d choose.
The Break and The Return make room for the part I most wanted to write about here. You get to find out what you enjoy, what you want to say, and what kind of love you’d choose with your voice intact.
There are three original, human-made mermaid illustrations (done on a computer, of course), along with reflection prompts and practices you can take at your own pace.
If you’ve been trying to understand the last relationship and find yourself looking forward to the next, I wrote the book with room for both.
You can read it for the pleasure of the story and come back to it when you want to hear your own answer more clearly.
RECOVER
Enmeshment Is Ursula
How to Reclaim Your Voice from the Tentacles
What kind of love would you choose with your voice intact? This illustrated guide helps you recognize enmeshment, hear what you want again, and make room for love on your own terms.